LEGO Disney › Pirates of the Caribbean · Set 4184-1 · 2011
Black Pearl
Overview
Minifigures







Easter Eggs
Set Value
Collector Appeal
Pro OnlyInvestor Appeal
Pro OnlyBrickVault earns commission through this link
External Links
Similar Sets










Black Pearl price and value
When Black Pearl (4184-1) came out in 2011 it cost $99.99. Sealed, it now sells for around $1,224.75, 12.2 times its retail price, or 18.2% a year over 15 years (the Pirates of the Caribbean theme averages +13.4% a year). Opened and complete with its box, it is worth around $1,016.54.
Over the past year its value has moved from $1,120.10 to $1,224.75 (+9.3%). The highest price we have recorded is $1,286.02 (Jun 2026) and the lowest is $1,020.78 (Aug 2025), across 60 price records since August 2025.
Of the 15 Pirates of the Caribbean sets with a market value, it ranks #1 by value, and it is one of 14 Pirates of the Caribbean sets released in 2011.
With 804 pieces it works out to $1.523 per piece at today's sealed value, above the Pirates of the Caribbean average of $0.798.
It comes with 7 minifigures, 4 of them exclusive to this set. Together the figures are worth about $578.59, 47% of the sealed set's value. The most valuable is Davy Jones at $371.91.
LEGO 4184-1 price history
| Year | Low | High | Average | Last |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $1,027.50 | $1,286.02 | $1,200.31 | $1,224.75 |
| 2025 | $1,020.78 | $1,256.56 | $1,104.95 | $1,256.56 |










